The Messengers follows a dysfunctional family composed of a father, mother, sullen teenager and mute toddler as they escape the big city and a tragic past for life on a sunflower farm. Unfortunately for them, their new home is inhabited by spirits who communicate their sorrow in physically harrowing ways.
I’ve never understood the appeal of The Messengers directors the Pang Brothers. The Eye was only passably entertaining, and Re-Cycle was one of the few films I have ever considered walking out of. Maybe it’s because The Pangs were among the first successful South Korean creators to come out of the Asian horror boom, but taking into consideration all the talent coming out of that country I can only imagine their days are numbered. If so, The Messengers may be the nail in the coffin.
Plot-wise, the film plays out like three or four movies mixed together, but unlike most I found those disparate horror conventions worked fairly well. Where the cross-breeding failed was in its mixture of styles. The inclusion of the rather overplayed Asian ghosts with the other more Western menaces was a good idea gone horribly wrong and didn’t do either camp any favours. The Messengers other major failing is in its characterization, with the underlying tension between family members turning out to be both a let-down and downright unbelievable. The impression one gets time and time again is that this family has almost no concept of either personal safety or responsibility for others. They constantly let each other out of their sight when it would be inadvisable in real life, let alone during a crisis. I was half expecting a character to fall off the roof because another character holding the ladder saw something shiny and let go to investigate. These people are precisely why natural selection is a great idea.
Surprisingly, there are a few good ideas buried in The Messengers. It’s tricky to plausibly keep the victim of ghostly encounters from fleeing and never coming back, but in the case of a relatively powerless and voiceless teenager there really isn’t any choice. Having the protagonist chained to the location by social pressures, rather than imprisonment of a physical or mental variety, is a novel idea that would definitely resonate with the intended audience. What teenager doesn’t feel as if they know all the answers, yet no one is willing to listen to them? While Kristen Stewart is only passable in the role of the family’s daughter, she excels in screaming, sobbing and freaking out, and that puts her well above the rest of the cast who hack out their roles. Another interesting characterization is that of the youngest child, able to see the ghosts but unable to voice his observations. The intriguing part about his role is that at almost no point in the movie does he realize the extent of the danger circling around him. There is something refreshing about watching a character in a movie react to blatant horror with awe and wonder.
To its credit, The Mesengers is one of the best of the bunch for PG-13 horror films of the past few years, though that’s about the most damning praise I ever hope to heap on a movie. Recommended only if you’re a sucker for recycled J-Horror (via Korea), jump scares or butt cracks.